For a long time I have been mulling over labels – Organic, Humanely Raised, etc., etc.
As a Clean Farmer, I have been tempted by these more than once. I don’t know about all those other farmers out there (who apparently have things figured out much better than me), but I’ve often thought that some label would help me sell product. BUT then I’m reined in by my ideals. I don’t buy these labels and I’m never going to.
I don’t mean I don’t buy organic when I’m shopping.
I mean I don’t buy labels as a solution to our need for clean food on every table.
It’s not that I think I’m immune to labels. I am from America, the land where, apparently, somebody is nobody unless they have a largely worthless college degree.
Wait, wait…before you start picking up something to throw – hear me out…
Reason #1:
I was talking to another sustainable farmer this weekend and he explained how his family operation began with conventional, chemical row-cropping, transitioned to organic, and is now back to non-gmo row-cropping, using one herbicide application for weed control.
Why?
After growing organic grains (which they were using to feed their hogs), they discovered that trying to clean all of the weeds out of their corn was such a monumental task negatively affecting both their time and their animals’ nutrient intake, they switched back.
And I didn’t argue with him (and I can’t fault him).
I think I have to credit this to farming and the realities it imposes on our modern, I-want-it-yesterday-and-only-this-way minds.
The important thing in this equation is that he didn’t hide it.
He admitted what he was doing and that it was what he had to do. He agreed it wasn’t ideal, but he was making his farm work.
Otherwise, his ideals would have stopped his farm from working altogether.
Reason #2
I sometimes think that my parents sadistically sent me to an all-boys, private, Catholic high school.
I know they really did it out of naive love, but sometimes…
Anyway, there were lots and lots of rules there.
Your hair couldn’t touch your eyebrows or ears or collar.
We had to wear dress shirts and ties, then no plaid dress shirts, then no stripes, then all solids.
The rules were literally never-ending. And it finally hit me why.
The more rules you make, the more ways folks try to find ways around them. Find ways around them, they will. Sometimes those end runs rank among mankind’s most clever achievements. Though ill-used, their is a certain wonderful genius in finding the loophole. The rulemakers have to keep making new rules to block the end runs.
And that’s my point. The more rules organic has made or will make (because people are always getting around the current ones), the more ways people figure out how to get around them.
Eventually what you end up with is a 6,000+ page tax code or organic code or whatever.
See, labels can’t fix our food because the rules governing those labels can’t fix us.
I know we’ve all heard the saying, “You can’t legislate morality”.
Organic is the perfect example of why.
If a farmer doesn’t start with doing unto others…then no label will fix the food they produce, making it truly clean. The law governing the farmer can’t be in a book. It has to be in, well, a heart – the farmer’s heart, to be precise.
And only by going to a farmer, learning how they farm, asking them questions, even visiting their operation can we truly know our food.
The farmer’s heart will shout to you in his farming.
So, maybe it’s time we stopped settling for mere labels and started talking…